November 14, 2016, 3:48 pm
One Big Thing: Mark Cuban and the half-baked protest
Mark Cuban has never been shy. It’s made him one the most famous member of his peer group and it’s actually quite refreshing to see Cuban eschew the stuffy rich owner archetype by being so engaged in Dallas’ affairs. He’s been good for the game in a multitude of ways, which makes last week’s little media dustup all the more surprising.
For those who missed it, the Mavericks, presumably (i.e. definitely) at Cuban’s directive, revoked the credentials of ESPN’s Tim McMahon and Marc Stein. McMahon had previously covered the Mavs before taking on more league-wide assignments while Stein is the sport’s second most notable insider. It led many to question what Cuban’s rationale was- it didn’t seem like there was personal animosity with the two reporters, but issues with the parent company seemed more than likely.
Before Cuban issued his statement, which we’ll get to momentarily, it seemed like a low road maneuver to punish two of the game’s best journalists for any issues with their bosses, especially considering that McMahon and Stein had never been unfair or overly critical of the Mavs to the public eye.
Any complaints Cuban had with ESPN should’ve been confined to the appropriate levels. To make the jobs of Stein and McMahon more difficult came across as strong headed at best and petty at worst. There had to be more to this than met the eye given the fact that this news broke out of nowhere.
As it turns out, Cuban’s move was a statement against what he sees as the growing trend towards automated reporting:
“Maybe I will be wrong but I see a direct path from the trends in coverage of games we are seeing over the last couple years to the automation of reporting on games and the curation of related content.”
On the surface that’s a strong statement that I happen to agree with a million times over. I might not be doing on-site reporting, but you’re reading the words that I slap together about basketball and for that I’m eternally grateful. The role of journalists and media is vital (he said, apropos of no particular recent event) though cost cutting measures have left many talented writers and reporters in search of steady work.
Lists, gifs and videos are just the way things are headed. Maybe we’re already there. It’s hard to ignore the nature of virality on the internet given the way that content is currently evaluated. Clicks are king, and that’s made crappy slideshows more common than ever. True reporting and analysis will always remain the backbone of a worthwhile news outlet but the role of an old school journalist has grown increasingly nebulous as sites scrounge for eyeballs.
Of course there’s also the fading spotlight of the Dallas Mavericks as The Worldwide Leader shifts its focus to more exciting, competitive teams. Surely that has nothing to do with it. But I digress.
Far be it from me to tell anyone how to stage their own protest, but it does beg the question of why McMahon and Stein felt the brunt of Cuban’s message when they would clearly stand on the same side of the fence.
Barring two excellent reporters from working Dallas’ home games only seems to push decision makers towards automated content. Not having a face in the room certainly limits your options, and if you’re so opposed to the idea of automated game reports then why give ESPN’s higher ups a chance to test it out?
It seems wrong to punish McMahon in particular, who was moved off the Mavs beat for a more high profile job. Upward advancement in this line of work isn’t thrown around freely and it’s quite clear that he made the jump on merit. The fact that it potentially came at the expense of Dallas-centric coverage is no reason to take it out on McMahon.
Luckily things were resolved by the end of the week, with Cuban and ESPN President John Skipper releasing joint statements on the matter.
Essentially, Stein and McMahon are back in the good graces while ESPN restates their commitment to use on-site reporting.
In the end, this looks to have been nothing more than a warning shot from Cuban. Maybe not even a warning shot- just a preemptive notice of “I really dislike the idea of automated reporting.” That’s all well and good, and Cuban’s point is both valid and valuable.
But what if ESPN hadn’t been so eager to work with Cuban? What if the ban lasted longer than five days? It goes to show that while the intent is there, the actions themselves were basically pointless and half-baked.
There’s a saying about how you shouldn’t poke the bear and while the stakes are much lower I think its essence applies here. I just don’t get why Cuban would go out of the way to draw attention to a practice that those punished by his protest aren’t engaging in. It’s like telling a kid not to eat candy for breakfast- they probably weren’t going to, but now that you brought it up the idea is floating around up there.
I respect Cuban for trying to protect and preserve the practice of on-site sports journalism. It’s a worthy cause to take up, but I’m just not sure what the intended outcome was on this one.
January 23, 2020, 3:08 pmIvica ZubacC, Los Angeles Clippers
Marc Stein of The New York Times is reporting that the Clippers are exploring the trade market to add a dependable big man and wing depth to the team.
The Clippers could use another big man to pair with Ivica Zubac and Montrezl Harrell, as well as another wing defender to play behind their superstar forwards. The Clippers are set with their core and will be doing their due diligence to round out the kinks of the roster before the stretch run.
Source: Marc Stein on Twitter
January 23, 2020, 3:02 pmDeAndre' BembrySF, Atlanta Hawks
DeAndre' Bembry (personal) will miss Friday's game against the Thunder as he deals with the passing of his aunt.
Our prayers go out to Bembry and his family. De'Andre Hunter could see a few extra minutes in his absence.
Source: Jameelah J on Twitter
January 23, 2020, 2:58 pmJosh RichardsonSF, Philadelphia Sixers
Josh Richardson (left hamstring strain) will be re-evaluated in two to three weeks after getting injured in the opening minutes of Wednesday's loss to the Raptors.
Richardson was ruled out for the game shortly after leaving, and this confirms the teams' fears that it will be a multi-week absence. Furkan Korkmaz was the primary beneficiary on Wednesday after Richardson left the game, with James Ennis and Shake Milton also getting extra minutes. Korkmaz is the guy to target of the group, though Joel Embiid's eventual return is sure to shuffle the rotation once again.
Source: Shams Charania on Twitter
January 23, 2020, 2:41 pmZion WilliamsonPF, New Orleans Pelicans
Pelican's coach Alvin Gentry said that Zion Williamson (right knee surgery) has no soreness or issues and went through a full practice on Thursday following the prized rookie's NBA debut on Wednesday night.
Williamson put on a show in the fourth quarter during Wednesday's game, and at one point, scored 17 straight points. He returned to the bench to end the game as the team takes a cautious approach with the highly-touted prospect. Williamson is as exciting a player as they come.
Source: Royce Young on Twitter
January 23, 2020, 2:33 pmEric BledsoePG, Milwaukee Bucks
Bucks GM Jon Horst relayed that the team is not interested in trading Eric Bledsoe saying, “We have no[t] talked to any teams about trading [Bledsoe], since the day that we traded for him.”
The Bucks have the best record in the league at 39-6 and sit 7.5 games ahead of the number two seed Miami Heat. The team does not need to make a huge splash to compete for the NBA Championship this season, but if they again fail to show up in the postseason, and Bledsoe fails to show up in the playoffs again, it could cause ripple effects on Giannis Antetokounmpo's future.
Source: NBC Sports
January 23, 2020, 2:03 pmJeremiah MartinPG, Brooklyn Nets
Jeremiah Martin and Chris Chiozza are being listed as available to play against the Lakers on Thursday.
The Nets will call up both of their two-way players ahead of a stretch of three games in four nights. Neither of these guards is on the fantasy radar.
Source: NBA Injury Report
January 23, 2020, 1:59 pmChandler ParsonsSF, Atlanta Hawks
Forward Chandler Parsons of the Hawks remains in the NBA's concussion protocol as he continues to receive treatment in California, while also covering and rehabbing from whiplash and a cervical disc injury suffered after being involved in a car crash.
This is a genuinely saddening story as not only is Parsons' playing career in doubt, but he is said to have suffered permanent damage after being struck by another driver who has been charged with a DUI. We wish Parsons all the best and pray he can make a full recovery.
Source: Marc J. Spears on Twitter
January 23, 2020, 1:50 pmWesley MatthewsSG, Milwaukee Bucks
Wesley Matthews (illness) is being listed as probable for Friday's game against the Hornets.
Matthews has put up value outside of the top-200 in both 9/8 cat leagues this season as he continues to be outplayed by Donte DiVincenzo. Matthews is nothing more than an occasional streamer for teams looking for extra threes on small slates.
Source: NBA Injury Report
January 23, 2020, 1:46 pmAnzejs PasecniksC, Washington Wizards
Anzejs Pasecniks (left ankle sprain) is being ruled out of Thursday's matchup with the Cavs.
Pasecniks run of fantasy value is pretty much over for now with Thomas Bryant and Davis Bertans returning to action, along with Rui Hachimura being cleared for full activities. Pasecniks is merely a depth option when healthy as the Wizards' frontcourt returns to health.
Source: NBA Injury Report
January 23, 2020, 1:41 pmNicolas ClaxtonPF, Brooklyn Nets
Nicolas Claxton (shoulder) is being listed as out for Thursday's game against the Lakers.
Claxton will join DeAndre Jordan (finger) on the sidelines for this one. Jarrett Allen is in line for all the run that he can handle in this primetime matchup.
Source: NBA Injury Report